We discussed in an earlier article how excess demand drives profit down the supply chain into industries with a lack of capacity. This in turn can drive investment to increase the supply in those industries such as oil or semiconductors.
There is a second path. Suppliers may decide they are happy with the status quo. The extra profit can be invested somewhere else. There has always been a product that attracts this kind of investment. This is the share of the whole.
By nature this does not exist in modern economies. It was the currency of feudalism tied to land, the source of food. Gold matched the fixed share instead of a variable valuation. Bitcoin was one that tried to replicate the gold economy. It had limited success even scratching the success of the USD run by the Federal Reserve. Central banks are rarely interested in deflation. They usually play against such policies.
Why? The answer is simple. Constitutions eliminated or reduced the power over the free will of citizens. Deflation effectively devalues labor relative to the money supply. Some economies can handle this up to a limit, when the retired generations can buy more due to productivity growth. Eventually the productive generations retire as well, smoothening the interest rate differences. The debt grows within a nation or economy in this case.
That kind of deflationary pressure creates a conflict of interest, when money piles up abroad. Growing foreign cash reserves try to influence and buy more. The process removes money from the system, creating deflation. The competition to build assets does not have a match to pay with. Foreign holders do not have the same buying interests.
Foreign money may have a side effect in this case as well. Foreign reserves may attract a less productive workforce with better wages. This pressure makes an economy more efficient with competitive products. That sells better at home eventually.
There is also an option, when foreign investors exchange their cash for government bonds. Typically this smoothens rates with the valuation. It is in the local currency. The government is the debtor, not the people. The currency valuation bears the risk.
Greece was an example that showed that government debt in foreign currency can lead to a deficit in democracy and state welfare. The result is oftentimes street protest. States are not designed to be debtors of res privata. They are designed to be a res publica.
There is another problem that investing profits elsewhere may generate. When oil profits build up, they may attract investors interested in a share of the whole like 0.5%, not the monetary value. Oil exports build such reserves, but if they are not invested in increasing that capacity the only goal becomes that 0.5% of the whole.
That percentage of money becomes like the land of a feudal warlord. This often has the side effect of conflicts over a bigger or smaller share of a pile that does not exist. People will be forced to migrate or change professions from what they paid for, and they won't understand why.
The side effect of excess monetary supply is oftentimes conflict. The benefactors are scarce, the imbalances are high, and the pressure on changing shares becomes a disruptor of a society. Long-term welfare promises are replaced with oligopolies. Commodity exports are a destabilizing factor with statistical confidence, whether it is Venezuela, Africa, the Middle East, or North Asia.
The argument is then to remove the adjective "debtor" from a nation. Nations cannot really be debtors. In the decades when this statistically applied to some countries, they were infected with high levels of autocracy, imbalances, or oligopolies. The same books talking about debtor nations also admit that the US was not a victim of such issues in the 1980s due to its openness. What happens is rather that the foreign currency debt of special interests is written on the government's accounts.
Will a younger generation work more to pay off an older generation's debt? It is unlikely, because it is impossible. Labor standards and management science already optimized the productivity of modern nations. What is more likely is that the debt will devalue a currency, or it will devalue the nation's assets if it is in a foreign currency.
This may even be useful for newer generations, if they use their civil rights wisely. Free capital markets can unblock the path for new businesses quickly. Trust can build from alumni, so that their technology can spread faster. Interest rates are good indicators. If they are high, the older generation's assets are too expensive. It is better to build their own with lower risks. If interest rates are low, it is easier to get old and new to compete. Customers win.